15 May Hillsboro Presbyterian Church Case Study
Overview
When Hillsboro Presbyterian Church received roofing quotes that ranged from $60,000 to $280,000 for the same property, they knew something wasn’t right. Without technical expertise, they were left trying to make sense of wildly different estimates, unsure of what was truly needed and whether the lowest bid could be trusted.
That’s where Alliance Consulting & Testing stepped in—to provide clarity, consistency, and confidence in a high-stakes decision.
“We received multiple roofing bids ranging from $60,000 to $280,000. We needed expert advice to fairly compare both the pricing and the proposed processes. Alliance generated a comprehensive specification to send to all contractors so that bids would be based on the same specifications. They were always available to answer questions throughout the process and consistently provided excellent service.”
The Challenge
Inconsistent Roofing Bids & Decision Paralysis
Without a clear process or independent insight, they risked either overpaying or cutting corners that could cost more down the road.
Roofing bids that varied by over $200,000 in total cost
No way to fairly compare what each contractor was actually offering
Risk of choosing the wrong contractor based on guesswork
Fear of hidden costs, low-quality installation, or future liabilities
The Solution
Independent Oversight & Standardized Scope
Hillsboro Presbyterian Church reached out to Alliance Consulting to bring structure and strategy to the process. Instead of trying to compare apples to oranges, Alliance worked directly with the client to create a consistent, transparent framework for evaluation.
Clarity across every roofing bid
Confidence in their contractor
Thousands saved, zero guesswork
Don’t guess. Get expert guidance before you commit.
Most roofing quotes aren’t written to be compared easily. They differ in terminology, assumptions, and levels of detail—which makes fair analysis nearly impossible for property managers or boards without technical knowledge.
This is where a roofing consultant adds real value:
- Breaks down hidden costs or exclusions
- Flags unrealistic timelines, vague warranties, or upsells
- Helps you choose based on quality and long-term value
Looking for an Independent Roofing Consultant?
Protect Your Investment — and Save Thousands
Confusing roofing bids can cost thousands more than necessary. Get expert guidance to compare quotes clearly, avoid hidden costs, and make the smartest decision for your property. Alliance helps you spend wisely—before you sign.